Craig admitted to providing false information to his partner, which was then included in a search warrant affidavit. He also admitted to misleading a Brooklyn assistant district attorney regarding the identification of a suspect. The detective further acknowledged failing to properly document investigative steps.
The investigation centered on a man identified as a gang lookout. Craig told a prosecutor that another detective had positively identified the man, but this identification had not yet occurred when the warrant was obtained. The search warrant was executed the day after it was signed, and evidence seized was later suppressed.
While Craig admitted to misconduct, he maintained he did not intentionally make false statements, stating he believed the suspect was well-known to police. The department judge found that Craig had cut corners to expedite the investigation, compromising his credibility and the integrity of the department.
Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch approved Craig's forced separation on August 7. The settlement requires Craig to retire immediately with his pension, forfeit suspension days and accrued leave, and agree not to seek reinstatement with the NYPD. This follows a previous disciplinary action in 2020 where Craig forfeited vacation days for striking a person and refusing to provide his name.