Freire was indicted on drug-related charges along with Brian Peralta Cabrera, who prosecutors accuse of supplying the fentanyl to Freire. The indictment does not specify the university, but Freire's attorney indicated it occurred at the Fashion Institute of Technology.

Prosecutors allege Freire pressured the women to use the drugs on March 18. Freire reportedly admitted to campus security that he had been with one of the women and found her unconscious afterward. He also stated he saw the other woman on the floor with her eyes rolled back.

Freire is accused of texting friends about the women's condition and sending photos while they were unconscious, waiting at least 40 minutes before seeking help. His attorney argued that Freire was not a drug dealer and that the women invited him over and asked for cocaine, describing the events as "dumb teenager things."