Mayor Zohran Mamdani stated his support for the ban, vowing that his administration would ensure the safety of workers and horses. Animal rights advocates have long campaigned for an end to the practice, with recent incidents highlighting concerns.

A carriage horse collapsed and died in June, followed by the death of a tourist, Romanch Mahajan, who fell from a runaway carriage horse in the park. Following Mahajan's death, a bill to ban carriage horses was renamed in his honor and a public hearing was held.

While the legislation aims to provide new economic opportunities for displaced drivers, the Transport Workers Union, which represents them, expressed concerns that the bill lacks concrete economic relief. Animal rights group NYCLASS and the Central Park Conservancy have supported the ban.